Did Borthwick Master the Art of Bench Selection?

In his recent column for BBC Sport, World Cup winner Matt Dawson highlights England's impressive squad depth following their victory over Australia in the first autumn international. Coach Steve Borthwick's selection showcased a blend of experience and talent, signalling a promising outlook as the team prepares for the upcoming Rugby World Cup in Australia.

Last updated: 11 October 2023 (BST)

What’s happening now

England's rugby team is currently riding a wave of optimism following their 25-7 victory against Australia. The win not only highlights the squad's depth and talent but also sets the stage for upcoming matches against Fiji, New Zealand, and Argentina. These games are crucial for building confidence and establishing a winning mentality as the team gears up for the 2025 Rugby World Cup in Australia.

Key takeaways

• England's squad depth is unparalleled, with many talented players vying for limited spots.
• The recent victory against Australia showcased a powerful bench, featuring several British and Irish Lions.
• Key positions such as full-back and fly-half remain competitive, allowing for tactical flexibility.

Timeline: how we got here

The current context of English rugby has evolved significantly over the past two years, particularly leading up to the 2025 Rugby World Cup. Notable milestones include:

• January 2023: Maro Itoje is appointed as England captain, bringing a new leadership style to the team.
• July 2023: England completes a successful summer tour to Argentina, igniting optimism for the future.
• October 2023: England defeats Australia in the first autumn international, signalling their readiness for upcoming challenges.

What’s new vs what’s known

New today/this week

The standout performance against Australia has renewed discussions about England's squad depth. Players like Henry Pollock have emerged as key contributors, showcasing their ability to perform under pressure. The victory also highlighted the effectiveness of Borthwick's strategic selections.

What was already established

Prior to this match, England had been building momentum through their summer tour and strong performances in previous fixtures. The emphasis on squad depth and leadership has been a consistent theme, with players showcasing their capabilities in various positions.

Impact for the UK

Consumers and households

As the England rugby team continues to perform well, public interest is likely to rise, positively impacting merchandise sales and viewership for upcoming matches. The success of the national team can foster a sense of national pride and community engagement amongst fans.

Businesses and jobs

Increased attention on rugby could lead to higher attendance at matches and growth in related businesses, from hospitality to merchandise sales. Local economies in cities hosting matches may benefit from increased visitor numbers.

Policy and regulation

The success of the English rugby team may influence discussions around sports funding and support from the government, as well as initiatives aimed at promoting rugby at grassroots levels.

Numbers that matter

• 25-7: The scoreline of England's victory over Australia, showcasing their defensive and offensive capabilities.
• 8: The number of consecutive wins for England, emphasizing their current form.
• 4: The number of matches scheduled against top-tier teams in the lead-up to the World Cup.

Definitions and jargon buster

• British and Irish Lions: A rugby union team made up of players from England, Ireland, Scotland, and Wales that tours every four years.
• Full-back: A position in rugby union primarily responsible for defending against opposing attacks and counter-attacking.
• Fly-half: A key playmaker position in rugby union responsible for directing the attack and making tactical decisions.

How to think about the next steps

Near term (0–4 weeks)

In the immediate future, England must focus on maintaining their winning streak against Fiji, New Zealand, and Argentina. These matches will be critical for assessing team performance and identifying areas for improvement.

Medium term (1–6 months)

Over the next few months, England should work on refining their strategies and solidifying key positions as they gear up for the World Cup. Performance consistency will be vital for building team confidence.

Signals to watch

• Player performances in upcoming matches to gauge squad depth and tactical effectiveness.
• Team dynamics and leadership styles as they evolve through the autumn internationals.
• Public and media reactions to performances, which can influence team morale and focus.

Practical guidance

Do

• Continue to support the team during the autumn internationals to foster national pride.
• Engage with local rugby clubs to promote the sport at grassroots levels.
• Stay updated on player selections and performances as the World Cup approaches.

Don’t

• Underestimate the importance of squad depth and its impact on performance.
• Dismiss the significance of the upcoming fixtures against strong competitors.
• Neglect to support initiatives aimed at growing rugby in schools and communities.

Checklist

• Monitor key player performances each week leading up to the World Cup.
• Evaluate the effectiveness of Borthwick's tactical decisions in matches.
• Engage with fan communities to enhance the overall rugby culture.

Risks, caveats, and uncertainties

While England's recent performances have been encouraging, the unpredictability of rugby means that form can change quickly. Factors such as injuries, player fatigue, and the quality of opposition play will continue to influence outcomes. Additionally, changes in coaching strategies or player dynamics could impact the team's consistency.

Bottom line

England's rugby team is currently in a strong position, with promising squad depth and a series of important matches ahead. Their ability to maintain form and build on recent successes will be crucial as they prepare for the 2025 Rugby World Cup. Fostering a winning culture and confidence will be key to overcoming future challenges.

FAQs

What is the significance of England's squad depth?

England's impressive squad depth allows for tactical flexibility and resilience, which will be vital as they approach the Rugby World Cup.

How can upcoming matches impact England's World Cup preparations?

Winning upcoming matches can build confidence, establish team dynamics, and contribute to a winning mentality ahead of the World Cup.

What role does leadership play in the current England squad?

Leadership from players like Maro Itoje, Jamie George, and George Ford contributes to a positive team culture, enhancing performance and cohesion.