Did VAR Get the Late Drama Right in Liverpool vs. Man City?

In a thrilling encounter between Manchester City and Liverpool, the Premier League champions secured a dramatic late victory with a 2-1 scoreline. However, the match was marred by controversy as a late goal from City was disallowed following a VAR review, sparking debate about the balance between the laws of the game and its spirit.

Last updated: 14 October 2023 (BST)

What’s happening now

Following a tempestuous match at Anfield, Manchester City claimed a significant three points against Liverpool, but not without a contentious VAR intervention that disallowed a last-minute goal. This incident has reignited discussions about the role of technology in football and its impact on the emotional landscape of the game. Fans and pundits alike are divided, with many expressing frustration over how VAR affects the flow and excitement of matches.

Key takeaways

Manchester City emerged victorious with a 2-1 win against Liverpool.
A dramatic late goal was disallowed following a VAR review for a foul.
The incident has reignited debates about the fairness and emotional impact of VAR.

Timeline: how we got here

The match took place on 14 October 2023, with significant events unfolding as follows:

14 October 2023: Manchester City faced Liverpool at Anfield, leading to a thrilling conclusion.
Last Minute of the Match: Rayan Cherki attempted to score an empty net goal after a Liverpool set-piece.
VAR Review: The review occurred due to a foul involving City striker Erling Haaland and Liverpool's Dominik Szoboszlai.

What’s new vs what’s known

New today/this week

The most notable development is the disallowed goal in the dying moments of the match, which has drawn widespread attention and criticism. VAR official John Brooks determined that a foul by Haaland on Szoboszlai warranted the intervention, despite the chaotic nature of the play.

What was already established

It is already known that VAR has been a contentious issue in football since its introduction, often dividing fans and analysts. This incident has further highlighted the challenge of balancing the strict enforcement of rules with the emotional experience of the game.

Impact for the UK

Consumers and households

For football fans in the UK, the disallowed goal has sparked discussions about the value of entertainment versus strict rule enforcement. As matches become increasingly scrutinised, the emotional highs and lows that fans experience may be affected, influencing attendance and viewership.

Businesses and jobs

Football clubs rely on the emotional connection of fans for revenue through ticket sales, merchandise, and broadcasting rights. The ongoing debates about VAR could potentially impact the profitability of clubs as fans reassess their engagement with the sport.

Policy and regulation

As VAR continues to be a point of contention, discussions about its implementation and regulation may evolve. The football associations may consider revisiting the guidelines surrounding VAR usage to better align with the expectations of fans and the spirit of the game.

Numbers that matter

2-1: The final scoreline in favour of Manchester City.
1: The number of goals disallowed by VAR in the match.
25: The distance in yards that Haaland was from goal when fouled.

Definitions and jargon buster

VAR: Video Assistant Referee, a technology used to review decisions made by the on-field referee.
Advantage: A rule that allows play to continue after a foul if the team that was fouled is in a favourable position.

How to think about the next steps

Near term (0–4 weeks)

In the immediate aftermath of this match, discussions surrounding VAR are likely to dominate sports media. Fans will be keenly watching how the Premier League addresses these concerns in future matches.

Medium term (1–6 months)

As the season progresses, the impact of VAR decisions will become clearer. Clubs will be keen to understand how their fortunes might be affected by such interventions.

Signals to watch

Future matches involving VAR reviews and their outcomes.
Fan engagement metrics and attendance at matches.
Official statements from football governing bodies regarding potential changes to VAR protocols.

Practical guidance

Do

Stay informed about VAR protocols and how they are applied in matches.
Engage in discussions about the impact of VAR on the game.

Don’t

Dismiss the role of technology in improving the accuracy of officiating.
Let frustrations overshadow the enjoyment of watching live football.

Checklist

Review previous match highlights to understand VAR implications.
Follow updates from the Premier League regarding VAR guidelines.
Engage with fan communities to share insights and thoughts on VAR.

Risks, caveats, and uncertainties

The ongoing debate around VAR is complex, with opinions divided on its effectiveness and fairness. While some argue that it enhances the game by ensuring correct decisions, others feel it detracts from the emotional experience of football. Uncertainties remain about how clubs and fans will adapt to these changes in officiating.

Bottom line

The recent Manchester City vs. Liverpool match showcased the tension between the strict application of football laws and the emotional highs of the sport. As VAR continues to evolve, fans will need to navigate a landscape where technology and tradition intersect, potentially reshaping their experiences in the Premier League.

FAQs

Why was the Manchester City goal disallowed?

The Manchester City goal was disallowed after a VAR review determined that a foul was committed by Erling Haaland, which affected the outcome of the play.

What is VAR?

VAR, or Video Assistant Referee, is a technology used to assist referees in making correct decisions during a match by reviewing key incidents.

How does VAR impact football matches?

VAR can change the outcome of matches by overturning decisions made on the field, which can affect the final score and overall match dynamics.