Will Women's 'Symbol of Love' Cutlery Fetch Big at Auction?

A Fascinating Look at the Cutlery Set of the Ladies of Llangollen

The upcoming auction of a historic cutlery set belonging to Eleanor Butler and Sarah Ponsonby, famously known as the Ladies of Llangollen, is set to captivate audiences and collectors alike. This remarkable 23-piece Harlequin cutlery set, along with an additional 10 pieces, not only holds significant monetary value but also represents a rich tapestry of history, love, and defiance against societal norms. The auction, scheduled for August 21 in Cambridge, offers a rare opportunity to acquire a piece of LGBTQ+ history that has long been overshadowed by traditional narratives. Steve Collins of Cheffins auction house emphasizes the importance of this sale, describing it as "a powerful symbol of love, legacy, and defiance."

But what makes this cutlery set so special? To answer this, we must delve into the extraordinary lives of Eleanor and Sarah, their relationship, and the societal context of 18th-century Wales that shaped their existence. The couple's story serves as an inspiration for modern narratives, notably the BBC series "Gentlemen Jack," which reflects the growing interest in LGBTQ+ histories and experiences.

The Historical Significance of Eleanor Butler and Sarah Ponsonby

Eleanor Butler and Sarah Ponsonby met in 1768 in Ireland and quickly developed a profound bond that would last for over 50 years. Both belonged to prominent Anglo-Irish families and were well-educated, making their decision to pursue a romantic relationship and live together in Llangollen all the more daring. Their existence challenged the conventions of their time, as they defied traditions like marriage, dressing in male clothing, and rejecting the roles society had prescribed for them.

Norena Shopland, a Welsh historian, highlights the importance of their story in understanding LGBTQ+ history. She notes that the artifacts associated with same-sex relationships are scarce, making their legacy all the more valuable. The Ladies have often been mischaracterized as "romantic friends," a notion that diminishes the significance of their bond. According to Shopland, "Diversity, sexual orientation, and gender identity have always been there," and the Ladies of Llangollen are a testament to that enduring truth.

A Symbol of Love and Defiance

The cutlery set, engraved with the initials of Eleanor and Sarah, serves as a powerful reminder of their unique relationship. The estimated pre-sale price of £800 to £1,200 reflects not just its material worth but its emotional and historical significance. It is a tangible connection to a couple who lived their truth in a time when doing so was fraught with challenges. The Ladies' legacy continues to inspire discussions about gender and sexual identity, reinforcing the idea that love knows no bounds.

The Life of the Ladies in Llangollen

In 1778, after negotiating with their families, Eleanor and Sarah left Ireland for Wales and purchased Plas Newydd, where they would live together for the next five decades. The picturesque town of Llangollen became the backdrop for their lives, allowing them to thrive in a community that, while initially bewildered by their relationship, ultimately came to embrace them. They were well-loved figures, receiving visits from notable personalities like Lord Byron, Percy Bysshe Shelley, and William Wordsworth, who were intrigued by their unconventional lifestyle.

The Ladies were known for their intellect and social grace, often engaging in conversations that challenged the norms of their time. They became renowned figures in Georgian high society, and their home became a gathering place for those who appreciated their unique perspective on life. Their correspondence reveals a deep affection for one another, filled with terms of endearment that indicate the emotional depth of their relationship.

Understanding the Societal Context

During the 18th century, same-sex relationships were often viewed through a lens of confusion and disapproval. Women who engaged in such relationships were often labeled as "sapphists," a term derived from the Greek poet Sappho, who wrote about love between women. This term reflected the broader societal attitudes that deemed same-sex relationships as "unnatural." Shopland explains that while society struggled to understand same-sex relationships, the affection that existed between Eleanor and Sarah was undeniable.

This societal backdrop made the Ladies' life together in Llangollen a radical act of defiance. They not only lived openly but also enjoyed the freedom to express their love in ways that were uncommon for women of their social standing. Their choice to dress in male clothing and ride horses astride was particularly controversial at the time, challenging the rigid gender norms that governed society.

Legacy and Historical Preservation

Following the deaths of Eleanor Butler in 1829 and Sarah Ponsonby two years later, their cutlery set was acquired by Richard Jebb, a land agent for Brynkinalt Estate, where the Ladies had been tenants. Nearly 200 years later, Jebb's descendant is bringing the cutlery back to auction, raising questions about the preservation of LGBTQ+ history. Norena Shopland advocates for the cutlery set to be returned to Plas Newydd, where it rightfully belongs. She emphasizes the importance of historical artifacts in telling the stories of marginalized communities, stating, "We have little amount of things to prove same-sex relationships throughout history."

The upcoming auction not only offers a chance to acquire a piece of history but also serves as a reminder of the ongoing struggle for LGBTQ+ rights and recognition. As collectors and history enthusiasts gather for this event, it is an opportunity to reflect on the legacies of those who have come before us and how their stories continue to shape our understanding of love and identity.

Conclusion

The cutlery set belonging to the Ladies of Llangollen represents much more than a collection of silverware; it embodies a narrative of love, resilience, and defiance against societal norms. As we look forward to the auction on August 21, we are reminded of the power of love and the importance of preserving history in all its forms. The story of Eleanor Butler and Sarah Ponsonby serves as a beacon of hope for those who continue to fight for their right to love freely, regardless of societal expectations. Their legacy challenges us to celebrate diversity and embrace the complexities of human relationships.

FAQs

Who were the Ladies of Llangollen?

Eleanor Butler and Sarah Ponsonby, known as the Ladies of Llangollen, were a famous lesbian couple who lived together in Llangollen, Wales, during the 18th century. Their relationship defied societal norms and has inspired many discussions about LGBTQ+ history.

What is the significance of the cutlery set?

The cutlery set is engraved with the initials of Eleanor and Sarah and represents their love and defiance against societal norms. It serves as a historical artifact that highlights the challenges faced by same-sex couples in the 18th century.

What will happen to the cutlery set after the auction?

It is hoped that the cutlery set will be returned to Plas Newydd, where it originally belonged, to preserve the legacy of the Ladies of Llangollen. Historian Norena Shopland advocates for this, emphasizing the importance of keeping such artifacts in their historical context.

As we ponder the stories of those who have come before us, what does love mean to you in today's world? #LGBTQHistory #LoveIsLove #LadiesOfLlangollen