Will Kickers Be Left Off NFL Rosters This Season?

Jude McAtamney, Charlie Smyth, and Mark McNamee, three former Gaelic footballers, find themselves in a challenging position after being waived by their respective NFL teams. With the regular season on the horizon, they are now available for other franchises to pick up or potentially join practice squads. This article explores their journeys, performances, and what lies ahead for these athletes in the competitive world of American football.

Last updated: 18 October 2023 (BST)

Key Takeaways

• Jude McAtamney was waived by the New York Giants and is aiming for a practice squad return.
• Charlie Smyth missed out on the New Orleans Saints' final roster but is eligible for the practice squad.
• Mark McNamee was not included in the Green Bay Packers' roster and is seeking opportunities elsewhere.

Jude McAtamney's Journey with the New York Giants

Jude McAtamney, a talented kicker from County Derry, had a promising pre-season with the New York Giants. He showcased his skills in several games, including victories against the New York Jets and the New England Patriots. McAtamney successfully converted 10 extra points and a field goal during these matches, demonstrating his ability to handle all kicking duties.

Despite his impressive pre-season performance, McAtamney lost out to veteran kicker Graham Gano when the Giants finalised their 53-man roster. Gano's experience and consistency likely played a significant role in the team's decision. McAtamney had previously been called up from the practice squad during last season when Gano sustained an injury, highlighting his potential value to the Giants.

What’s Next for McAtamney?

As the regular season approaches, McAtamney remains a candidate for the Giants' practice squad. If Gano's pre-season form does not attract interest from other teams, the Giants might choose to bring McAtamney back, ensuring they have a capable backup. The upcoming weeks will be critical for McAtamney as he awaits offers from other franchises.

Charlie Smyth's Experience with the New Orleans Saints

Charlie Smyth, hailing from County Down, faced a similar fate with the New Orleans Saints. For the second consecutive season, he was waived as the team opted for Blake Grupe as their primary kicker. Despite this setback, Smyth's pre-season performances were commendable. He played in the second half of each game, consistently demonstrating his kicking prowess, including a notable 52-yard field goal in a loss against the Denver Broncos.

Eligibility for the Practice Squad

One silver lining for Smyth is his eligibility to return to the Saints' practice squad under the international player exemption slot. This allows him to continue training with the team and possibly re-enter the roster should the need arise during the season. As teams often face injuries and roster changes, Smyth's chances of being recalled remain viable.

Mark McNamee's Opportunity with the Green Bay Packers

Mark McNamee, from Dublin, also saw his journey with the Green Bay Packers come to an unexpected halt. He participated actively in pre-season games, taking all kick-offs in his debut against the New York Jets and scoring a 43-yard field goal in a subsequent match against the Indianapolis Colts. However, his performance was marred by a missed field goal attempt and an extra point, which may have influenced the team's decision-making.

Looking Ahead for McNamee

With the Packers opting for regular kicker Brandon McManus, McNamee now seeks opportunities elsewhere. Like his counterparts, he remains open to being picked up by other franchises or potentially returning to the Packers' practice squad. His pre-season experience may give him an edge as teams evaluate their kicking options.

The Competitive Landscape of NFL Kicking

The NFL is known for its competitive landscape, especially in specialised positions such as kickers. Teams often prioritise experience and reliability, which can make it challenging for newcomers to secure a permanent spot. However, the ability to perform under pressure during pre-season can significantly influence a player's prospects.

Factors Influencing Team Decisions

Several factors contribute to a team's decision-making regarding kickers:

• Experience: Teams often favour kickers with proven track records.
• Performance in Pre-Season: Consistent scoring and handling pressure can sway decisions.
• Injury Considerations: Teams may opt for backups based on injury histories of current players.
• Contract and Salary Cap: Financial implications can also dictate roster choices.

Final Thoughts

As Jude McAtamney, Charlie Smyth, and Mark McNamee navigate this transitional phase in their careers, they remain hopeful for new opportunities. Their performances in pre-season have showcased their abilities, leaving the door open for potential offers from other franchises or a return to their current teams. The next few weeks will be crucial as the regular season kicks off, and teams solidify their rosters.

In the evolving world of the NFL, where opportunities can arise swiftly, these athletes must stay ready while aiming to leave their mark in American football. How will their journeys unfold in the coming months? Only time will tell. #NFL #AmericanFootball #Kickers

FAQs

Can Jude McAtamney return to the New York Giants' practice squad?

Yes, McAtamney is eligible to return to the Giants' practice squad if they decide to bring him back, especially if their primary kicker does not perform well.

What are Charlie Smyth's chances of making the Saints' roster?

Smyth has a chance to make the Saints' roster again through the practice squad, as he is eligible under the international player exemption slot.

What does being waived mean for Mark McNamee?

Being waived means McNamee is no longer on the Packers' roster but is available to be picked up by other teams or added to the practice squad.

What factors do NFL teams consider when selecting kickers?

Teams typically consider experience, performance during pre-season, injury history, and financial implications when selecting kickers.

What can these players do to improve their chances of being picked up?

These players can focus on enhancing their skill sets, maintaining physical fitness, and demonstrating their abilities in any opportunities that arise, including workouts with other teams.