What Happened When a 12-Year-Old Girl Threatened a Migrant with an Axe in Dundee?

A viral video showing a man being confronted by a youth brandishing an axe has sparked widespread controversy, particularly on social media. The man, Fatos Ali Dumana, insists he did nothing to provoke the encounter, which has drawn attention from high-profile figures, including Tommy Robinson and Elon Musk, who amplified misinformation surrounding the incident.

Last updated: 31 October 2023 (BST)

Key Takeaways

• Fatos Ali Dumana was confronted by a group of youths, one wielding an axe and a knife.
• Claims surfaced on social media suggesting Dumana was following the girls, which he denies.
• A 12-year-old girl has been arrested for possession of offensive weapons.
• High-profile figures, including Elon Musk, contributed to the spread of misinformation.
• Scottish authorities are addressing the misinformation and its impact on community cohesion.

The Incident in Dundee

The incident took place on 23 August 2025, in St Ann Lane, Dundee. Footage recorded by 21-year-old Fatos Ali Dumana shows a tense confrontation where two young girls approached him aggressively. One of the girls, brandishing an axe and a knife, shouted threats while the other accused Dumana of following her sister, who is only 12 years old.

Context of the Viral Footage

In the clip, Dumana is heard responding to the threats, saying, “Yeah, yeah, show the knife, show the knife.” The situation escalated quickly, leading to the police being called after the video circulated widely on social media. Following the incident, police arrested a 12-year-old girl for possession of offensive weapons, indicating the seriousness of the situation.

Misinformation and its Consequences

As the video gained traction online, various unsubstantiated claims began to emerge, with some suggesting that Dumana was a “migrant” following the girls. This narrative was further propagated by public figures, including Tommy Robinson, who has a history of controversial statements regarding immigration and community issues.

The Response from Authorities

Police Scotland issued a warning regarding the spread of misinformation, emphasising that Dumana had been approached by the youths rather than the other way around. Chief Superintendent of Police Scotland stated, “We are aware of misinformation being shared on social media… inquiries are ongoing.”

Fatos Ali Dumana's Perspective

In interviews following the incident, Dumana expressed his frustration with the portrayal of him online. He stated, “I have seen the social media and it’s blown up. I never touched her. I swear on my life, I have a baby now. I would never hurt someone.” Dumana, who moved to the UK from Bulgaria in 2021, insisted he was simply on his way to the shops with his wife when the confrontation occurred.

The Impact of Social Media Narratives

The incident highlights the power and potential dangers of social media narratives. Prominent figures such as Elon Musk, who retweeted claims about the incident, can significantly influence public perception. Musk questioned the police's actions regarding the arrest of the young girl, suggesting that it was inappropriate for the government to act against individuals defending themselves.

Community Reactions

The incident has sparked a heated debate within the community, with many calling for a more nuanced understanding of the events. Scotland’s First Minister, John Swinney, condemned the spread of misinformation, stating that it undermines community cohesion. He noted, “We must be careful about the narratives we promote, as they can lead to fear and division.”

Legal Context and Police Actions

The legal implications of the incident remain significant. The 12-year-old girl is set to be referred to the relevant authorities, and police have continued their inquiries. This brings to light important discussions around youth behaviour, weapon possession, and the responsibilities of local law enforcement.

Understanding Offensive Weapons Legislation

In the UK, possessing an offensive weapon can lead to serious legal consequences. Under the Criminal Justice Act 1988, it is illegal to have an offensive weapon in a public place without lawful authority or reasonable excuse. This law aims to reduce violence and ensure public safety.

What Happens Next?

As investigations continue, it will be crucial to monitor how the narrative unfolds in media and public discourse. The implications of misinformation, particularly on social media platforms, can have lasting effects on individuals involved and the wider community.

Addressing Misinformation in Community Dialogue

Community leaders and law enforcement must work together to address the misinformation stemming from this incident. Open dialogues about the truth of events and the consequences of spreading false narratives are essential in rebuilding trust among residents.

Conclusion

The confrontation between Dumana and the youths raises significant questions about safety, community relations, and the role of social media in shaping public perception. As the situation develops, it is essential for all parties involved to focus on the facts and consider the implications of their actions and statements.

Will this incident lead to changes in how communities engage with social media narratives? Only time will tell. #DundeeIncident #Misinformation #CommunitySafety

FAQs

What happened in the viral video from Dundee?

A video from Dundee showed Fatos Ali Dumana confronted by two girls, one wielding an axe and a knife. Dumana claims he did not provoke the encounter.

Why was the 12-year-old girl arrested?

The 12-year-old girl was arrested for possession of offensive weapons after the confrontation with Dumana, highlighting the seriousness of the situation.

What role did social media play in this incident?

Social media amplified the narrative surrounding the incident, with various unsubstantiated claims being spread, leading to misinformation about Dumana's actions.

What are the legal implications of carrying offensive weapons in the UK?

In the UK, carrying offensive weapons without lawful authority can lead to severe legal consequences under the Criminal Justice Act 1988.

How have community leaders responded to the incident?

Community leaders, including Scotland’s First Minister, have condemned the spread of misinformation, emphasising the need for cohesion and understanding within communities.