Is There Really No Chaos in Reform-Run Councils?

Reform UK's deputy leader Richard Tice has defended his party against allegations of chaos in the councils it governs, asserting that they are on track to deliver substantial financial savings. He emphasised ongoing efforts to reduce waste and improve efficiency, especially in County Durham, amidst recent controversies involving party councillors. With local elections approaching in 2026, Tice is optimistic about the party's prospects in north-east England.

Last updated: 27 October 2023 (BST)

Key Takeaways

• Richard Tice claims Reform UK is successfully saving money in County Durham councils.
• Controversies arose after the resignation and suspension of party councillors.
• Upcoming local elections in 2026 are seen as a significant opportunity for the party.
• Proposed reforms to council pension funds could yield substantial savings.
• Concerns raised by Pensions UK regarding the feasibility of proposed savings.

Context of the Claims

Reform UK, a political party aiming to reshape local governance, has faced scrutiny after recent events in County Durham. Two councillors have resigned, and a third has been suspended amid allegations related to their conduct. Tice is adamant that these incidents do not reflect chaos, instead portraying them as isolated occurrences that do not detract from the party's overall success.

Recent Councillor Controversies

The situation began to unravel when John Bailey resigned due to ill-health in June. Shortly after, Andrew Kilburn, who had just been elected for the Benfieldside division, stepped down after failing to declare his employment with the council, a situation that raised questions about transparency. The resulting by-elections are estimated to cost taxpayers around £20,000 each, a point which Tice has acknowledged but downplayed as part of the larger picture of financial prudence.

Future Elections and Strategic Goals

As local elections approach in May 2026, Tice is enthusiastic about Reform UK's chances, particularly in the north-east. He believes the party can make significant inroads in areas such as Sunderland, Newcastle, South Tyneside, and Gateshead. Tice's assertion that the party will stand candidates in every seat reflects a commitment to broadening its influence in local governance.

Financial Strategy and Savings Plans

At the core of Tice's statement is a promise of financial reform, particularly concerning how council pension funds are managed. He claims that the party's reforms could lead to savings in the hundreds of millions of pounds, which could be redirected to either reduce council tax or enhance funding for essential services like social care.

Challenges to Proposed Reforms

Despite Tice's optimism, the feasibility of such significant savings has been questioned by Pensions UK, which argues that the local government pension scheme is already one of the most effective in the world. The organisation stresses that any proposed changes should be supported by substantial evidence and well-structured plans. This pushback highlights the complexities of reforming established systems, particularly in finance.

Impact on Local Taxpayers

One of the pressing issues at Durham County Council is a consultation regarding changes to council tax support schemes that could see the most disadvantaged residents facing higher taxes. While Tice promotes the idea that overall efficiency will benefit all residents, the immediate implications of tax adjustments raise concerns about fairness and the potential impact on vulnerable populations.

Current Council Initiatives

The Reform UK party is also looking into specific projects, such as the Milburngate development in Durham and a proposed waste management scheme. Both initiatives are part of a broader strategy to demonstrate effective governance and resource management. Tice insists that the focus remains on cutting waste and improving the delivery of services, which he believes will resonate with voters.

Public Sentiment and Support

Tice claims to have witnessed growing public support during his recent visits to Sunderland, where he and the party chairman, Dr David Bull, engaged with local voters. The enthusiasm expressed by constituents is seen as a positive indicator for the party's future electoral performance. However, translating this support into actual votes will be crucial in the upcoming elections.

Looking Ahead

The landscape for local governance in the north-east is set to change significantly in the next few years. As Reform UK positions itself as a viable alternative, it faces the challenge of overcoming past controversies while presenting a clear vision for the future. Tice's confidence in the party's ability to deliver financial savings and effective governance will be tested in the 2026 elections.

With the potential for both successes and challenges ahead, how Reform UK navigates this complex political terrain will be essential. Will they manage to translate their current support into electoral victories while addressing the concerns raised by their critics? Only time will tell.

FAQs

What recent controversies has Reform UK faced in County Durham?

Reform UK has faced controversies involving the resignation of two councillors, one due to ill health and another for failing to declare employment with the council. A third councillor has been suspended due to allegations about social media posts.

What are the financial savings proposed by Reform UK?

Richard Tice claims that reforms to council pension funds could save hundreds of millions of pounds, which could be used to reduce council tax or improve services like social care.

When are the next local elections for Reform UK?

The next local elections are scheduled for May 2026, during which all seats in Sunderland, Newcastle, South Tyneside, and Gateshead will be contested, along with a third of seats in North Tyneside.

What concerns have been raised about the proposed pension fund reforms?

Pensions UK has questioned the feasibility of significant savings from proposed reforms, citing the effectiveness of the existing local government pension scheme and the need for evidence-based policy changes.

How does Reform UK plan to address council tax issues?

Reform UK plans to cut waste within councils to potentially alleviate financial pressures on taxpayers. However, proposed changes to council tax support might lead to higher taxes for the poorest residents, which raises concerns about fairness.