Why Was a Holocaust Survivor's Daughter Arrested During Her Interview on Palestine Action?

Carolyn Gelenter, the daughter of a Holocaust survivor, was arrested during a protest advocating for Palestine Action, a group recently banned under anti-terror laws. Despite her detention, Gelenter remains committed to supporting the group, asserting that it is crucial to voice dissent against perceived injustices, particularly regarding the ongoing situation in Gaza.

Last updated: 17 October 2023 (BST)

Key Takeaways

• Carolyn Gelenter, 67, was arrested while protesting against the ban on Palestine Action.
• The Home Office proscribed Palestine Action in July 2023, making support for the group potentially punishable by up to 14 years in prison.
• Gelenter's father was a Holocaust survivor, which shapes her perspective on justice and activism.
• She argues that the current UK laws are authoritarian and stifle necessary protests against ongoing violence in Gaza.
• The UK government has recently suspended 30 arms export licences to Israel amidst international scrutiny over its actions in Gaza.

Background on Carolyn Gelenter

Born and raised in London, Carolyn Gelenter's life has been profoundly influenced by her father's harrowing experiences as a Polish Jew during World War II. Izku Gelernter, her father, was likely a victim of the Holocaust, with his grandparents murdered in a concentration camp. Surviving the war, he faced further persecution in the Soviet Union but ultimately found refuge in the UK, where he served in the military.

Carolyn's upbringing instilled in her the values of justice, empathy, and the importance of standing up against oppression, making her recent activism all the more poignant. Her experiences have led her to reflect deeply on what it means to be a Jew in today's world, particularly in the context of ongoing conflicts.

The Arrest: Circumstances and Reactions

During the protest in Parliament Square, which saw over 900 arrests, Gelenter was detained while speaking to a journalist. She emphasised the importance of amplifying diverse Jewish voices, particularly those opposing the actions of the Israeli government in Gaza. Despite being informed of her arrest under anti-terror laws, she maintained her stance, stating, "I am the daughter of a Holocaust survivor," a sentiment that highlights her personal connection to issues of persecution and injustice.

Her arrest has sparked further discussions about the implications of the UK's anti-terror legislation, particularly regarding freedom of expression and the right to protest. In her post-release interview, she expressed a determination to continue her activism, asserting that she would not be silenced by fear of legal repercussions.

Legal Context: The Proscription of Palestine Action

The ban on Palestine Action by the Home Office in July 2023 followed significant incidents, including damage to RAF planes estimated at £7 million. This legal proscription categorises the group as a terrorist organisation, leading to severe penalties for supporters. Critics argue that such measures are overly harsh and suppress legitimate dissent.

As a result of this designation, individuals like Gelenter, who wish to stand in solidarity with Palestine Action, face serious legal risks. The maximum sentence of 14 years in prison for supporting the group raises questions about the balance between national security and civil liberties.

The Ongoing Conflict in Gaza

The situation in Gaza has garnered significant international attention and outrage. With escalating violence and humanitarian crises, many activists, including Gelenter, view the UK government's arms exports to Israel as complicit in the suffering of Palestinians. The recent suspension of arms export licences, while a step in the right direction, has not alleviated the anger felt by many protestors.

Gelenter's assertion that "Israel is still committing a genocide" reflects a growing sentiment among activists who believe that the international community must take more decisive action to address the humanitarian crisis. This perspective is further supported by a declaration from prominent genocide scholars, who have labelled the situation in Gaza as genocidal.

Political Responses and Implications

In the wake of growing protests, political leaders in the UK, including Sir Keir Starmer, have begun to reconsider their positions on Palestine. Starmer has indicated that the UK will recognise Palestine if certain conditions, such as a ceasefire, are met. This shift suggests that public pressure is influencing political discourse regarding the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

Despite these developments, Gelenter and others express frustration that more decisive action has not been taken sooner. The ongoing protests are a testament to the urgent need for governmental accountability and a reassessment of foreign policy regarding Israel and Palestine.

The Personal Impact of Activism

For Carolyn Gelenter, activism is not merely a political statement; it is a deeply personal commitment shaped by her family's history. Her experiences and the legacy of her father drive her to take a stand against what she perceives as injustices, paralleling struggles faced throughout history. She articulates a powerful motivation to act, stating, "I felt like I had to do something because it feels so important."

This commitment to activism is reflected in her decision to participate in protests, even at the risk of arrest. Gelenter embodies the belief that individuals have a moral obligation to confront injustice, drawing parallels between her father's experiences during the Holocaust and the plight of Palestinians today.

Future of Palestine Action and Ongoing Activism

The future of Palestine Action remains uncertain in light of the ban and the legal implications for its supporters. However, activists like Gelenter are determined to keep the conversation alive, advocating for the rights of Palestinians and urging others to join the movement. Her assertion that "I just can’t sit by" resonates with many who feel compelled to take action in the face of injustice.

As public awareness grows regarding the situation in Gaza and the implications of UK foreign policy, it is likely that activism will continue to evolve. The ongoing protests serve as a reminder that the fight for justice is far from over, and individuals like Gelenter are pivotal in keeping the momentum alive.

Conclusion

Carolyn Gelenter's story is one of resilience, reflection, and a commitment to justice informed by her family's history. Her recent arrest has only strengthened her resolve to advocate for Palestinian rights and challenge the UK government's approach to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. As the situation in Gaza unfolds, the voices of activists like Gelenter will remain crucial in driving change and holding those in power accountable.

How will the UK government respond to the mounting pressure from activists and the international community regarding its stance on Israel and Palestine? The ongoing dialogue and activism may shape future policies and public perceptions for years to come. #PalestineAction #HumanRights #Activism

FAQs

What is Palestine Action?

Palestine Action is a group that advocates for Palestinian rights, often through direct action and protests. It was proscribed as a terrorist organisation by the UK government in July 2023.

Why was Carolyn Gelenter arrested?

Carolyn Gelenter was arrested during a protest against the ban on Palestine Action for allegedly supporting the group, which has been designated as a terrorist organisation under UK law.

What are the legal implications of supporting Palestine Action in the UK?

Supporting Palestine Action can lead to severe legal consequences, including imprisonment for up to 14 years, due to its status as a proscribed organisation under anti-terror laws.

What has been the international response to Israel's actions in Gaza?

International outrage has mounted over Israel's actions in Gaza, leading to some countries, including the UK, suspending arms exports to Israel amidst accusations of human rights violations.

How does Carolyn Gelenter's background influence her activism?

As the daughter of a Holocaust survivor, Carolyn Gelenter's family history informs her perspective on justice and oppression, motivating her to advocate for Palestinian rights in light of her father's experiences.