Did Monaghan Confront Referee About Alleged Wafer Bite?

In a dramatic quarter-final match of the Women's Rugby World Cup, Ireland's captain Sam Monaghan raised concerns regarding an alleged biting incident involving French player Axelle Berthoumieu and Ireland's Aoife Wafer. This incident occurred during the second half of the match, which Ireland lost 18-13 to France. The match officials did not take action during the game, but discussions about potential retrospective consequences are underway.

Last updated: 25 October 2023 (BST)

Key Takeaways

• The alleged biting incident occurred during Ireland's quarter-final match against France.
• Aoife Wafer was reportedly bitten on the arm by French player Axelle Berthoumieu.
• Match officials did not take action during the game, despite concerns raised by the Irish team.
• Retrospective action could lead to a ban for Berthoumieu if found guilty.
• Reactions from former players highlight the seriousness of the incident.

The Incident: A Closer Look

The match, held at Sandy Park, was a tightly contested affair. Ireland started strong, leading 13-0 at one point. However, the incident that has since overshadowed the result occurred in the 42nd minute when Aoife Wafer, making her tournament debut, was allegedly bitten by Axelle Berthoumieu. The footage captured immediately after the incident shows Wafer examining her arm, which raised alarm bells among her teammates and coaching staff.

Officials' Responses

Despite Monaghan's efforts to bring the incident to the attention of referee Aimee Barrett-Theron, no immediate action was taken. Monaghan stated, "I spoke to the referee. Aoife told me, I didn't see it myself, but I spoke to the referee and asked them." This raises questions about the protocols in place for handling such incidents during matches. Monaghan’s comments suggest a desire for accountability and a clear process when allegations of foul play arise.

Potential Consequences for Berthoumieu

The possibility of retrospective action looms over Berthoumieu. If World Rugby decides to review the incident, there could be significant consequences, including a potential ban. This could impact not only Berthoumieu's future participation in the tournament but also set a precedent for handling similar incidents in women's rugby.

Reactions from the Rugby Community

The rugby community has responded strongly to the incident. Former England World Cup winner Maggie Alphonsi expressed her dismay, stating that such behaviour should not be tolerated in the sport. She emphasised the need for punishment if Berthoumieu is found guilty, asserting, "It's sad because we've been celebrating the women's game in this World Cup." Alphonsi's sentiments resonate with many who believe that the integrity of the sport must be upheld.

Deborah McCormack, a former Scotland international, highlighted the potential impact of the incident on the match’s outcome. She stated, "It could have had an effect on the game if it was looked at at the time," pointing out that the lack of immediate action could undermine the fairness of the competition. McCormack's comments underscore the importance of vigilance and accountability in officiating.

Focus on the Game

Despite the controversy, the Irish team is attempting to maintain focus on their performance and future matches. Stacey Flood, who scored a try in the quarter-final, remarked that the incident was ultimately up to the officials. "We just have to get on with it and it's not our decision to make," she said. This attitude reflects a commitment to the sport and a determination to move past the incident.

Coaching Staff Comments

Irish head coach Scott Bemand, who did not witness the incident himself, asserted that the team's leadership had done their part in reporting it to the officials. "In terms of process, your on-pitch leadership would mention to the referee," he stated, highlighting the protocols that should be followed in such situations. Bemand’s comments suggest an understanding of the complexities involved in officiating high-stakes matches.

Looking Ahead

The incident raises important questions about player conduct and the responsibilities of match officials in ensuring a fair playing environment. As the Women's Rugby World Cup progresses, all eyes will be on World Rugby's response to this incident and whether it will lead to changes in how such matters are handled in the future.

FAQs

What happened during the Ireland vs France match?

During the quarter-final match, Aoife Wafer allegedly suffered a bite from French player Axelle Berthoumieu, leading to concerns raised by Ireland's captain Sam Monaghan.

Was any action taken regarding the alleged biting incident?

No action was taken during the match, despite Monaghan raising the issue with the referee. However, World Rugby may review the incident for potential retrospective action.

What are the potential consequences for Axelle Berthoumieu?

If found guilty of biting, Berthoumieu could face a ban from future matches, which could affect her participation in the tournament.

How have former players reacted to the incident?

Former players like Maggie Alphonsi and Deborah McCormack have condemned the incident, stressing the need for accountability and its potential impact on the game.

What is the Irish team's stance on the incident?

The Irish team is focusing on their performance and future matches, with players like Stacey Flood emphasising the need to move on from the incident.