Which Manchester United Star Should Ruben Amorim Reignite? Wayne Rooney Weighs In!

Following a disappointing 3-0 defeat to Manchester City, Wayne Rooney has called on Manchester United manager Ruben Amorim to include Harry Maguire more regularly in the starting lineup. Rooney’s comments highlight the urgent need for leadership and resilience within a struggling team that currently finds itself in 14th place in the Premier League.

Last updated: 04 October 2023 (BST)

Key Takeaways

• Wayne Rooney advocates for Harry Maguire's inclusion in Manchester United's starting XI.
• The team is currently positioned 14th in the Premier League with only four points from four matches.
• Maguire’s leadership skills are deemed essential during this challenging period.
• Amorim's preferred tactical formation has not effectively utilised Maguire’s strengths.
• The defeat to Manchester City raised concerns over the team's fighting spirit and resilience.

Current Situation at Manchester United

Manchester United’s recent performance has sparked widespread concern among fans and analysts alike. After a promising pre-season and a competitive showing against Arsenal, the team’s form has drastically declined. With only four points from their opening four matches, including a notable win against Burnley secured by a last-minute penalty, the club's current trajectory raises questions about both the players and the managerial approach.

Rooney's Support for Maguire

Rooney, a legendary figure at Manchester United, has publicly stated that Harry Maguire should be a regular starter. The former United captain pointed out that Maguire’s absence from the starting lineup has contributed to a lack of leadership on the pitch. Rooney remarked on how England missed Maguire's influence during the Euros, emphasising the importance of having a player who can inspire and motivate others, particularly in challenging situations.

“Harry should be starting,” Rooney said. “I heard Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink talking about it and how much England missed Harry Maguire at the Euros because he’s a leader. I’m sat there thinking how is he not playing with the three defenders who are playing.”

The Tactical Dilemma

Ruben Amorim, who took over as manager, has favoured a three-man defensive setup. However, this system has not provided a consistent role for Maguire, leading to speculation about whether Amorim can effectively utilise the squad's strengths. The manager's tactics have come under scrutiny, especially after the dismal showing against City, where critics noted a lack of aggression and determination from the players.

Concerns Over Team Spirit

Rooney also expressed concerns about the team’s mentality, particularly during critical moments of the match against Manchester City. He highlighted that there seemed to be a lack of desire among players to make a statement, as there were few tackles or attempts to halt the City onslaught, even as the scoreline grew more severe.

“At the Etihad, you can lose that game but I didn’t see a tackle – even when it goes to 2-0, 3-0,” Rooney noted. “I didn’t see anyone say ‘do you know what, I’m not having this’ and taking a yellow card or putting a tackle in.”

The Financial Implications

Further compounding the situation, the financial decisions made by the club have come under criticism. Former goalkeeper Peter Schmeichel has accused Manchester United of wasting £73 million on players who may not fit the team's needs. This scrutiny of transfer decisions adds another layer of pressure on Amorim, who must navigate both player performance and financial expectations.

What’s Next for Manchester United?

As Manchester United prepares for its upcoming fixtures, the focus will be on how Amorim responds to the mounting pressure. The calls for Maguire’s inclusion in the starting XI may force the manager’s hand as he seeks to restore confidence and stability to a team in turmoil.

The next few matches will be critical in determining the trajectory of the season. If Amorim fails to secure positive results, it could lead to further questions about his position and approach. Meanwhile, Maguire’s potential return to the starting lineup could serve as a catalyst for renewed energy and determination within the squad.

Conclusion

In the face of adversity, leadership becomes paramount. Rooney's insistence on including Harry Maguire in the starting lineup reflects a broader need for Manchester United to rediscover its fighting spirit. As the team grapples with its identity and performance levels, the upcoming weeks will be pivotal. Can Amorim adapt his tactics to harness the full potential of his players, or will the team continue to falter? Time will tell.

#ManchesterUnited #HarryMaguire #WayneRooney

FAQs

Why is Harry Maguire not starting for Manchester United?

Harry Maguire has not been a regular starter under manager Ruben Amorim, who favours a three-man defence that may not fully utilise his strengths. This has drawn criticism from former players like Wayne Rooney.

What does Wayne Rooney think about Manchester United’s current performance?

Wayne Rooney is concerned about the lack of leadership and resilience in Manchester United’s performances. He believes that Harry Maguire should be included in the starting lineup to provide that leadership.

How has Manchester United's season started?

Manchester United has had a difficult start to the season, currently sitting in 14th place in the Premier League with just four points from four matches, including one win against Burnley.

What are the implications of losing to Manchester City?

The defeat to Manchester City highlighted significant issues within the squad, including a lack of aggression and fighting spirit. It has raised questions about the managerial approach and players' commitment.

What are the financial concerns regarding Manchester United's squad?

Financial scrutiny has arisen concerning transfer decisions, with some, including Peter Schmeichel, arguing that the club has wasted significant funds on players who do not fit the team’s needs.