Is the iPhone 17 Pro's Scratch-Gate Real? YouTuber Exposes Weakness in Camera Design!

The iPhone 17 Pro has garnered attention for its impressive design and durability features; however, recent tests suggest a significant vulnerability that could lead to widespread issues for users. YouTuber JerryRigEverything has highlighted a problem with the phone's anodized aluminium finish, specifically at the sharp edges of its camera plateau, which may result in what can be termed “Scratch-Gate.”

Last updated: 19 October 2023 (BST)

Key Takeaways

• The iPhone 17 Pro features a unique anodized aluminium finish.
• Durability tests reveal vulnerabilities at the camera plateau’s sharp edges.
• Anodizing provides a tough surface but struggles on sharp corners.
• Overall, the iPhone 17 Pro remains structurally sound and resilient to bending.
• Using a protective case is advised to mitigate potential damage.

Understanding Anodizing and Its Implications

Anodizing is a process used to enhance the aluminium's resistance to wear and corrosion. This method involves submerging raw aluminium in an acidic solution and applying an electric current, which forms a protective oxide layer. This layer is known for its hardness, rating just below diamond on the Mohs scale, providing scratch resistance that is generally beneficial for devices like smartphones.

Design Choices at the Core of the Issue

Apple has a reputation for prioritising aesthetics alongside functionality. In the case of the iPhone 17 Pro, the design team opted for sharp, angular edges on the camera plateau instead of rounded corners. While this creates a sleek and modern look, it compromises the durability of the anodized finish. According to JerryRigEverything's findings, the sharp edges are prone to chipping, especially under normal usage conditions.

The Vulnerability Exposed

During his stress tests, Jerry used commonplace items like a coin and a key to assess the durability of the camera plateau. While the flat surface remained intact, the sharp corners chipped immediately, exposing the raw aluminium. This suggests that wear and tear in this area is not just a possibility but a likelihood for users who do not use a case.

Industry Standards and Recommendations

Interestingly, international standards for anodizing suggest that sharp corners should be rounded to enhance the adhesion of the anodized layer. Apple’s decision to maintain sharp corners appears to lean heavily towards design aesthetics, potentially jeopardising the longevity of the device in everyday situations.

Structural Integrity: A Mixed Bag

Despite the concerns surrounding the camera plateau, the overall structural integrity of the iPhone 17 Pro remains robust. Jerry's bend test demonstrated that the device is one of the strongest iPhones Apple has produced. The solid aluminium unibody design and a reinforced frame contribute significantly to its durability, making it less susceptible to bending or breaking under pressure.

What This Means for Users

While the iPhone 17 Pro is structurally sound, users need to be aware of the specific vulnerability at the camera plateau. As the tests have shown, the aesthetic choices made for this area could lead to significant wear over time, which may detract from the overall experience of owning this premium device.

Protective Measures: Cases and Accessories

To mitigate the risk of damage, users are strongly advised to invest in a protective case that covers the camera plateau adequately. Here are some tips for choosing the right case:

• Full Coverage: Ensure the case provides full coverage over the camera plateau to protect against scratches.
• Material: Look for cases made from durable materials like silicone or hard plastic.
• Design: Opt for designs that incorporate raised edges around the camera to absorb impacts.

Conclusion: A Cautious Approach

The iPhone 17 Pro is undoubtedly a significant upgrade in terms of design and functionality, but potential buyers should approach with caution regarding its durability. The sharp edges of the camera plateau represent a clear trade-off between aesthetic appeal and long-term usability. As the “Scratch-Gate” phenomenon unfolds, it emphasises the importance of protective accessories in maintaining the device's pristine condition.

As Apple continues to innovate, users will be keen to see how future models address these design challenges. Will the next iteration offer a more durable solution, or will aesthetics continue to take precedence? Only time will tell. #iPhone17Pro #DurabilityTests #TechTrends

FAQs

What is anodizing and why is it used on the iPhone 17 Pro?

Anodizing is a process that enhances aluminium's resistance to wear and corrosion by creating a hardened oxide layer. Apple uses this process to improve the durability of the iPhone 17 Pro's aluminium frame.

What is the "Scratch-Gate" issue with the iPhone 17 Pro?

"Scratch-Gate" refers to the vulnerability of the iPhone 17 Pro's anodized finish, particularly at the sharp edges of the camera plateau, which are prone to chipping and scratching.

How can I protect my iPhone 17 Pro from scratches?

To protect your iPhone 17 Pro from scratches, it is recommended to use a protective case that covers the camera plateau and provides additional cushioning against impacts.

Is the iPhone 17 Pro fragile?

No, the iPhone 17 Pro is not considered fragile overall. It has passed rigorous durability tests, including bend tests, proving it is structurally solid.

What should I consider when buying a case for my iPhone 17 Pro?

When buying a case, look for full coverage over vulnerable areas, durable materials, and designs that protect against impacts while allowing easy access to features.