Is Keir Starmer Right to Call Reform's Migrant Policy Racist and Immoral?

Sir Keir Starmer has strongly condemned Reform UK's proposal to abolish indefinite leave to remain (ILR) for migrants in the UK, calling it "racist" and "immoral". This contentious policy, unveiled by party leader Nigel Farage, could potentially lead to the deportation of hundreds of thousands of legally residing individuals. Starmer's remarks come as Labour faces challenges in polling and leadership amidst their annual conference.

Last updated: 23 October 2023 (BST)

Key Takeaways

• Starmer labels Reform UK's policy on ILR as racist and immoral.
• Labour aims to double the time required to gain ILR from five to ten years.
• Public opinion is divided on the issue, with a YouGov poll showing significant opposition to scrapping ILR.
• Reform UK argues that their policy prioritises British citizens over foreign nationals for welfare benefits.
• Starmer emphasises the need for unity within Labour to combat the rise of Reform UK.

The Context of Indefinite Leave to Remain (ILR)

Indefinite leave to remain is a status granted to migrants that allows them to live and work in the UK without any time restriction. Currently, individuals can apply for ILR after five years of lawful residence. This status is crucial as it not only secures their right to stay but also grants access to various public services, including healthcare and welfare benefits.

Under the proposals from Reform UK, the ILR would be scrapped altogether. Instead, migrants would need to reapply for visas under stricter conditions, potentially affecting their legal standing and ability to remain in the UK. The implications of this policy could be profound, affecting hundreds of thousands who have made their lives in the UK lawfully.

Labour's Response to Reform UK's Policy

Starmer's comments came during an interview on the BBC's Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg programme, where he did not shy away from calling out the moral implications of such a policy. He stated, "It's completely different to say we're going to reach in to people who are lawfully here and start removing them. They are our neighbours, they're people who work in our economy, they're part of who we are. It will rip this country apart."

This statement underscores a significant shift within Labour's approach to immigration, which has been under scrutiny in recent years. Traditionally, Labour has supported more inclusive immigration policies, viewing migrants as integral to the economy and society.

Public Sentiment on Immigration Policy

According to a recent YouGov poll, the public is divided on the issue of ILR. While 58% of Britons oppose the removal of ILR for current holders, there is a notable 44% who support ending the policy. This division suggests that immigration remains a contentious issue in British politics, reflecting broader concerns about national identity and economic stability.

Starmer acknowledged the frustrations of voters who may be drawn to Reform UK, citing the "14 years of Tory failure" as a backdrop to their discontent. He expressed understanding for those who feel left behind economically, noting that many voters want tangible changes after years of stagnant living standards.

Reform UK's Counterarguments

In response to Starmer's criticism, Zia Yusuf of Reform UK asserted that Labour's stance implies a burden on taxpayers to support foreign nationals indefinitely. Yusuf stated, "Labour's message to the country is clear: pay hundreds of billions for foreign nationals to live off the state forever, or Labour will call you racist." This encapsulates the party's narrative that prioritising British citizens in welfare access is essential for societal cohesion.

Reform UK's policy is positioned as a means to ensure that migrants contribute to society while preventing what they term as "welfare tourism". This rhetoric resonates with some segments of the public who feel that immigration policies should favour those who have a clear commitment to contributing to British society.

Labour's Strategic Positioning

As Labour's annual conference unfolds, Starmer faces the dual challenge of rallying party unity and addressing voter concerns. He emphasised the need for collective action against Reform UK, stating that Labour must fight for "the soul of this country". This call to arms suggests a pivotal moment for the party as it seeks to redefine its identity and reconnect with its base.

Starmer's leadership has faced scrutiny, particularly following recent losses and challenges within the party. The upcoming days may provide him with the opportunity to clarify Labour's stance on immigration and other pressing issues, potentially shaping the narrative ahead of the next general election.

The Future of Immigration Policy in the UK

Looking ahead, the discourse around immigration and ILR is likely to intensify. With Labour's proposed changes to ILR and the potential ramifications of Reform UK's policy, the immigration landscape in the UK is at a crossroads. Starmer's position may influence policy discussions moving forward, especially as the public continues to grapple with the implications of immigration on social services and national identity.

As debates unfold, it is essential for political leaders to balance the needs of the economy with the rights of those who have built their lives in the UK. The challenge lies in crafting policies that are both fair and sustainable, ensuring that the voices of all communities are heard in the process.

Calls for Unity in the Face of Division

Starmer's plea for unity within the Labour Party is especially poignant in light of increasing polarisation in UK politics. He remarked that now is not the time for "introspection or naval-gazing", highlighting the urgency of addressing public concerns and countering the rise of parties like Reform UK.

As the Labour Party seeks to regain its footing, the upcoming weeks may prove crucial in shaping its identity and electoral strategy. The ability to articulate a clear, compassionate, and practical approach to immigration will be vital in winning back the trust of voters.

FAQs

What is indefinite leave to remain (ILR)?

Indefinite leave to remain (ILR) is a status that allows migrants to live and work in the UK without any time restrictions. It is typically granted after five years of lawful residence.

What are the proposed changes to ILR by Labour?

Labour plans to double the time required to gain indefinite leave to remain from five years to ten years, as part of a broader strategy to manage immigration effectively.

How does Reform UK aim to change immigration policy?

Reform UK proposes to abolish indefinite leave to remain and implement stricter visa reapplication rules for migrants, arguing that this prioritises British citizens in welfare access.

What is the public opinion on abolishing ILR?

A YouGov poll indicates that 58% of Britons oppose abolishing ILR for current holders, while 44% express support for ending the policy altogether.

What did Keir Starmer say about Reform UK's immigration policy?

Starmer labelled Reform UK's proposal to scrap ILR as "racist" and "immoral", arguing that it unfairly targets those who are lawfully residing in the UK.

As the political landscape evolves, what are your thoughts on how immigration policies could shape the future of the UK? #ImmigrationDebate #LabourParty #ReformUK